"We can not save all we construct" says commenter

On this week’s feedback replace, readers are discussing the announcement that Kenzo Tange’s modernist gymnasium is ready to be demolished.

It was confirmed this week that the post-war landmark accomplished in 1964 by Pritzker Structure Prize-winning architect Kenzo Tange in Takamatsu, Japan, will probably be demolished. Dezeen readers responded to the information within the feedback part.

Tom Roberts was upvoted for commenting “it’s an oddly fascinating constructing that shouldn’t be misplaced”.

“A exceptional constructing that it might be in Japan’s curiosity to preserve,” noticed James Dunnett. “Conserving one constructing doesn’t rule out creating extra elsewhere.”

Marius was in a extra sensible temper, saying “we can not save all we construct”.

“The constructing is not match for function,” stated an equally unbothered Sharad Majumdar. “I look ahead to no matter comes subsequent.”

Hideous, oddly fascinating or exceptional? Be a part of the dialogue ›

Elizabeth Roberts combines two buildings into one for a Catskills ski home

“A easy resolution to provide a unbelievable consequence”

Brooklyn studio Elizabeth Roberts Architects accomplished a cedar alpine home within the Catskills Mountains that connects two gabled kinds underground. On the entire, commenters beloved the venture.

Tony365, nonetheless, was conflicted, saying “it’s a pretty set of buildings. The match and end are nice. However I kinda hate it.”

“The size messes together with your head,” stated JZ. “You consider this as a modest, cozy cottage, nevertheless it’s 3,500 sq. ft with three full and two half bogs!”

However Richard Leonard was unequivocal in his love, discovering it to be a “nice instance of a easy resolution (utilizing the grade to bury the related quantity) to provide a unbelievable consequence (two volumes at avenue degree that really feel a lot smaller).”

“Nice decisions all through; the finishes are beautiful (drooling over the tile and the white oak) and the plan is impeccable. Lovely work,” they continued.

What do you make of this cedar-clad Catskills venture? Be a part of the dialogue ›

The Loop rendering
Urb proposes 93-kilometre biking freeway “to make Dubai probably the most related metropolis on earth”

“Raises extra questions than it seeks to reply”

Structure studio Urb proposed creating The Loop as a coated freeway for cyclists and pedestrians that might wrap round Dubai and commenters weren’t impressed.

Muckers270 thought the proposal was “an incredibly unhealthy venture that raises extra questions than it seeks to reply.” Alfred Hitchcock concurred, saying: “Additional proof of what occurs when there’s far an excessive amount of cash and no consciousness and even widespread sense.”

“To be honest, you most likely want air-con in Dubai to encourage biking and biking however would not it make sense to cowl present streets with some form of cover and encourage strolling and biking in a three-kilometre radius for a begin?” requested Zea Newland.

In the meantime Jacopo was discouraged, saying “typically you surprise why we trouble doing inexperienced single-family properties when individuals are allowed to make a glass snake of conditioned air in the midst of the desert 93-kilometres lengthy.”

Is the air-conditioned Loop a good suggestion for Dubai? Be a part of the dialogue ›

Anish Kapoor NYC bean sculpture in Tribeca
Iwan Baan pictures Anish Kapoor sculpture squashed underneath New York skyscraper

“The utter irrationality of it”

In New York, photographer Iwan Baan launched photos of Anish Kapoor’s long-awaited reflective sculpture on the base of Herzog & de Meuron’s 56 Leonard Avenue skyscraper.

Betty Rubble expressed emotions different commenters agreed with: “I get a giant cost out of this. The utter irrationality of it. The strain of that huge constructing resting on it, going to make an enormous pop any second… Kicks you within the frontal cortex.”

“I saved smiling – even laughed – as I learn the article,” stated Charlie Bing. “This appears like a particular piece of labor.”

Ken Steffes had enjoyable considering of nicknames for the sculpture, saying “a very good title could be ‘refried bean’ or ‘Beano’.”

Was JB being cynical once they commented “it is a very nice gimmick by one of many easiest gimmick mongers”?

Gimmick or masterpiece? Be a part of the dialogue ›

Feedback replace

Dezeen is the world’s most commented structure and design journal, receiving hundreds of feedback every month from readers. Hold updated on the newest discussions on our feedback web page and subscribe to our weekly Debate publication, the place we characteristic one of the best reader feedback from tales within the final seven days.