On this week’s feedback replace, readers are discussing a vibrant secondary faculty in China, which Hint Structure Workplace has designed as a “celebration of creativity”.
Outlined by its brightly colored volumes and sweeping curves, the Haikou Jiangdong Huandao Experimental College was created as a retreat from conventional types of training.
“The areas created stimulate creativeness and shock, as an alternative of merely following the principles and laws,” Beijing-based Hint Structure Workplace informed Dezeen.
“Le Corbusier is alive and effectively”
Commenters have been captivated by the college, with Archill hailing it as “an training in attractive design”.
“Love, love, love every part about this!” agreed Louise Smith, whereas Thithyphuth was reminded of nice initiatives previous, commenting “Le Corbusier is alive and effectively in China”.
Ken Robertson acquired probably the most upvotes for his remark, which branded the college “so assured, so fluid, so good”.
However not all readers have been fairly so smitten. Jb thought the constructing seemed a bit of old style, calling it “a celebration of creativity circa 1980”.
Idracula, in the meantime, thought the design seemed a bit of an excessive amount of like the children have been left in cost. “Designed by the pupils or the architects?” they questioned.
Do you assume the mission passes the check? Be a part of the dialogue ›
“I doubt Ferruccio Lamborghini would approve”
Additionally stoking loads of debate within the feedback part this week was Lamborghini’s first residential mission in Europe. Named Tierra Viva, Lamborghini stated that the event’s design “is instantly impressed” by its supercars.
However commenters weren’t racing to sing its praises.
Zee referred to as the villas “soulless and bleak”, whereas Pa Varreon branded them “ridiculous and useless”.
“Can be approach cooler if all of the doorways open the Lamborghini approach,” posited Claus, whereas Albia400 quipped “can be nice if these by no means bought constructed”.
“As with Bugatti, Lamborghini ought to follow what they know,” argued Alfred Hitchcock. “They make lovely automobiles. this mission, they do not make lovely structure. I doubt Ferruccio Lamborghini would approve.”
Different commenters weren’t satisfied the villas have been very in step with Lamborghini’s aesthetic. “Seems quite Audi to me,” joked Shepherd, whereas Seb thought the mission was extra akin to “the Toyota Corolla of villa design”.
What are your ideas on Tierra Viva? Be a part of the dialogue ›
“Has the whiff of hubris about it”
Scandinavian studios Henning Larsen and White Arkitekter are designing Stockholm Wooden Metropolis, a mass-timber growth within the Swedish capital that is set to grow to be the “world’s largest picket metropolis”.
In response to its developer Atrium Ljungberg, the town will use extra timber than some other mission in growth and is designed to have the “serenity of a forest”.
Commenters criticised the event for failing to see the wooden for the timber.
“Serenity of a forest?” disputed AJ. “That may be achieved by planting timber in the identical house [rather than] constructing this folly to serve the egos of the self-righteous and vapid architects and builders.”
Nick De St Croix was on the identical web page, asking “can this presumably be sustainable? Perhaps when judged in isolation however aggregated along with all different wooden initiatives throughout the planet? I doubt it. This has the whiff of hubris about it.”
Different commenters questioned its practicality. “This higher be coming with the world’s greatest hearth station,” stated Stefanos S, whereas A Haig provided a extra light-hearted concern and wished to know “will there be bears?”
Have commenters been too fast to dismiss Stockholm Wooden Metropolis? Be a part of the dialogue ›
“How and why is that this particular?”
Readers have been additionally left unimpressed this week by a 24-storey mixed-use constructing that US studio Hickok Cole designed utilizing ChatGPT.
The constructing, which incorporates a inexperienced roof and a swimming pool, was designed for an unspecified city web site and accommodates retail, workplace, residential, lodge and library house.
Responding to mission architect Jack Lynch’s prediction that specialised AI chatbots will begin to be built-in into software program generally utilized by architects, Tim commented “nice, as a result of if Revit wasn’t already annoying to make use of as is, now it may be suggesting the best way the design ought to be executed”.
Salamoon was equally unmoved. “How and why is that this particular?” they wrote. “Seems kinda unusual.”
“Exhausting to argue that it’s not a results of the Shake ‘n Bake AI design course of,” agreed Marius.
Don Bronkema, although, was much less cynical concerning the growth, calling it “pleasingly verdant”.
Are AI chatbots the way forward for architectural software program? Be a part of the dialogue ›
Dezeen is the world’s most commented structure and design journal, receiving 1000’s of feedback every month from readers. Maintain updated on the newest discussions on our feedback web page and subscribe to our weekly Debate e-newsletter, the place we characteristic one of the best reader feedback from tales within the final seven days.
The put up "So assured, so fluid, so good" says commenter appeared first on Dezeen.